Smart Self Storage Gets the Green Light for Its Final Two Buildings While a Proposed Bank Branch on Route 82 Heads Back for More Work
MACEDONIA, Ohio – On Nov. 16, the Macedonia Planning Commission approved the last phase of a self storage project on Bavaria Road. A proposed Citizens Bank branch in Macedonia Commons was sent back with a long list of changes, and the commission continued two other items to December.
All five members were present: Kevin Westbrooks, Scott Wallenhorst, Jason Roberts, Christine Meske and Michael Varhola. The commission also approved the Oct. 19 minutes.
Smart Self Storage Phase Two Approved
Steve Kresse, owner of Smart Self Storage at 8231 Bavaria Road, asked to build Buildings G and H. These are the last two of eight buildings the commission approved for the site in 2023.
Kresse said he split construction into two phases. Buildings A through F were finished in February. The original approval lapsed after one year, so he had to come back for the rest.
His submittal lists Building G at 20,507 square feet and Building H at 6,713 square feet. Together they are about 1,678 square feet smaller than what was approved before. Kresse said the new buildings will match the existing ones in height, materials and color. The stormwater system was designed for all eight buildings and will not change.
Planner Flags Gaps Between Plans and What Was Built
City Planner Brian Frantz said he had no problem with the request itself. The commission had approved essentially the same plan before. His Nov. 7 memo, however, listed several places where the plans and the site do not match.
Two plan sets with different revision dates were submitted. Kresse explained that only the sheets changed during Phase 1 construction were given new dates. Frantz asked for one consistent set.
The aerial photos also showed that some approved trees were missing. Kresse said Eastern White Pines planned for the back of the site were removed to build a rock spillway for the stormwater pond. A black fence was also put on the wrong side of the pond. He blamed a miscommunication with his contractor and said the fence will be moved, because that area is needed for snow storage.
Other details came up as well:
- A retaining wall on the approved plan was never built. Kresse got written approval from the neighboring property owner to grade onto that land, which makes the slope gentler without a wall.
- Kresse said the wetlands on the site were removed under a nationwide permit from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
- The back wall of Building H will double as a retaining wall. It will be designed and sealed by an engineer.
- The site has no dumpster. Kresse said he makes very little trash, but he is keeping a spot west of Building H in case one is needed later.
City Engineer Joe Gigliotti pointed out that the as-built survey shows every existing building with the same finished floor elevation, to the hundredth of a foot. That figure also matches the 2023 plan, so he asked Kresse’s surveyor to check it.
A city building official told Kresse that inspectors work from the approved drawings. If a dumpster is on the plan, it has to be built, or the plan has to come back for a change.
Approval With Conditions
The commission approved the plan subject to administrative review of a revised, consistent set of plans. The revised set must address the items in the planner’s memo and those raised at the meeting. Commissioners also waived the trees that could not be planted because of the spillway. The record notes the fence must be moved to its approved location.
Citizens Bank Sent Back for Site and Design Changes
The second item was a preliminary review of a 3,010 square foot Citizens Bank branch at 8210 Macedonia Commons Blvd. The plans call for building it on 0.46 acres split from the shopping center’s 19.80 acre parent parcel along Route 82.
Lot Split Brings Variance Questions
Frantz’s Nov. 8 memo said creating a separate lot inside existing parking brings at least nine possible variances. The proposed lot was 20,038 square feet, but the code requires 30,000. Several setbacks also fell short of the 25 feet required.
The applicant team brought a new lot drawing to the meeting. They said it is larger than 30,000 square feet and meets the 25 foot setbacks on all three sides. Two issues may remain. One is a setback near the brick enclosure for the Tesla charging equipment. The other is whether the lot meets the code’s definition of lot width, which Frantz said depends on how deep the lot is, not just its frontage.
The team said the shopping center owner will stay on as landlord, with the bank built for Citizens. The lot split is for tax and legal reasons, they said. The shopping center’s cross access agreement would still apply.
Parking and the Route 82 Entrance
The code requires 16 parking spaces. The plan shows 14 beside the bank plus five more across a drive aisle. Frantz said reaching those five means walking across two lanes of traffic, which made him uneasy. The applicant said the center as a whole has about 120 more spaces than the code requires, and would still have about 95 extra with the bank.
Traffic at the private intersection just inside the Route 82 entrance got the most attention. Gigliotti said his main worry is a driver waiting to turn left into the bank, with cars backing up behind onto Route 82.
He asked for angled parking on the north side of the bank so traffic there would flow westbound. He also said the plan’s left turn lane changes direction too sharply for cars to use it. Commissioners suggested making the drive aisle south of the bank eastbound only.
The applicant has moved the ATM farther down the lane, making room for seven cars to line up. Members said that eased their concerns. The team also agreed to drop the plastic flexible posts along the ATM lane and keep a solid yellow line. Some members worried drivers would not know they could drive over the posts to get out of the lane.
A Different Idea for the Building
Before the vote, Gigliotti sketched another layout for the applicant. Turning the building 180 degrees would put the ATM on the other side, and drivers would no longer need to turn left near Route 82. He said it could also eliminate the front yard parking variance.
“Don’t let parking drive this. Let circulation drive it,” he said.
Architecture Comments
Commissioners asked for brick detailing on the plain wall facing the ATM lane. They pointed to the Chase bank built nearby as an example. Members also said the rooftop mechanical screen would be visible from Route 82, which sits higher than the site. They asked the team to raise the roofline or lower the equipment. The applicant agreed to study both.
The commission continued the item to its January meeting, though the team can return in December if the work is ready. The motion covers the site plan, the architecture and the possible variances. Frantz has recommended that the commission wait for Board of Zoning Appeals action on any variances before approving a site plan.
Burlington Signs and Fairfield Inn Continued
At the applicant’s request, the commission continued Burlington’s sign request to December. Frantz said the city’s records contain conflicting past decisions on whether the stricter shopping center sign standards apply to that plaza. Members asked for a short memo so they can settle the question formally. City staff will also contact the plaza owner.
Commissioners also continued the proposed Fairfield Inn hotel at 240 E. Highland Road to December. The applicant had been continued to November but did not follow up. Members said continuing it again was fair to the applicant, because otherwise the application would lapse. Staff will reach out to the developer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Macedonia Planning Commission approve on Nov. 16?
It approved Phase 2 of Smart Self Storage at 8231 Bavaria Road. The phase adds Buildings G and H and is subject to administrative review of revised plans.
Where is the proposed Citizens Bank in Macedonia?
The 3,010 square foot branch is proposed at 8210 Macedonia Commons Blvd. It would be built on a new lot split from the Macedonia Commons shopping center near Route 82.
Why was the Citizens Bank plan continued?
The commission wants changes to traffic flow, parking, lot size and building design. Several variances may also be needed from the Board of Zoning Appeals.
When will Citizens Bank return to the Macedonia Planning Commission?
The item was continued to the January meeting. The applicant may return in December if revised plans are submitted in time.
What happened with the Fairfield Inn hotel proposal in Macedonia?
The commission continued the Fairfield Inn proposal at 240 E. Highland Road to December so the application would not lapse.





















